Journal Information
Vol. 44. Issue. 6.November - December 2024
Pages 769-920
Vol. 44. Issue. 6.November - December 2024
Pages 769-920
Letter to the Editor
Full text access
Renata, my nephrologist, can children's literature act as a tool to raise awareness and prevent kidney disease?
Renata, mi nefróloga, ¿puede la literatura infantil actuar como instrumento de sensibilización y prevención de la enfermedad renal?
Visits
117
M. Dolores Ojeda Ramíreza, Sergio Garcia Ramosa, Paula Mansodel Realb, Julia Audije-Gilb, M. Dolores Arenas Jiménezb,
Corresponding author
mdarenas@friat.es

Corresponding author.
a Servicio de Nefrología, Hospital Universitario Poniente, El Ejido, Almería, Spain
b Fundación Renal, Madrid, Spain
This item has received
Article information
Full Text
Bibliography
Download PDF
Statistics
Figures (1)
Tables (1)
Table 1. Results for each item pre- and post-intervention for children and family members.
Full Text
Dear Editor,

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a silent epidemic with a concerning economic and psychosocial impact on Public Health.1 Despite this, there is a lack of awareness among the general population regarding the implications and scope of this condition,2 which represents an obstacle to early detection and treatment. To improve kidney health, it is essential to understand this disease and how to prevent it.

In this context, schools play a vital role in educating children on scientific-health issues, as recognised by the World Health Organization in various programmes.3 Nonetheless, children and young people are undervalued in national health plans on CKD.4 They are often rendered invisible as health promoters, and the reality is that they play an essential role in literacy and the dissemination of knowledge in their family and social environment.

Given this perspective, and considering the paucity of studies in the scientific literature on the impact of kidney health literacy in schools, this preliminary research raises a question: can children act as drivers of health education in their immediate environment and contribute to the prevention of CKD?

In order to shed light on this issue, the impact of a talk-workshop on CKD with 21 pupils from the 3rd year of Early Childhood Education (age 5 years), from the Arco Iris Nursery and Primary School (Aguadulce, Almería), and on their families, was analysed. The activity consisted of reading the illustrated children's book Renata, my nephrologist,5 written and devised by the Renal Foundation, as well as conducting a series of associated workshops.6 Knowledge before and after the initiative was assessed using an ad hoc questionnaire (pre- and post-intervention) adapted for children and adults (who were not present during the activity).

The initial hypothesis was that the talk-workshop would improve pupils' knowledge about CKD, and that they would pass on what they had learned to their families. The average grade of the children improved significantly after the intervention (from 2.43 [SD 2.18] to 9.19 [SD 1.17] in the final evaluation [p < 0.001]), as did the grade of their relatives, although to a more moderate extent (from 6.81 [SD 1.29] at baseline to 8.10 [SD 1.48] after the initiative [p = 0.024]).

These data show that, after the activity with the pupils, their families' level of knowledge increased. Other international research projects have also shown that, after lessons at school, children discuss health issues at home, increasing their parents' knowledge7 and encouraging lifestyle changes in their families.8 Kidney health education programmes in schools (through teacher training, school support nursing and investment in resources by institutions) have a direct impact on literacy throughout society (Fig. 1).9

Fig. 1.

Diagram of Bronfenbrener's ecological model (Handbook of Child Psychology. Hoboken, USA: John Wiley & Sons; 2007) on the relationship between the development of an individual and his/her environment, adapted as a theoretical framework for literacy in chronic kidney disease.

(0.25MB).

One worrying finding, however, is the family members' relative lack of background knowledge on kidney-related issues and kidney health. A large proportion of adults did not know many of the answers: a quarter had never heard of the speciality of Nephrology, approximately half thought that kidneys hurt when affected by CKD or did not know what the marker of kidney function is (creatinine), and less than 10% were familiar with the available treatment options (Table 1). These data show that many adults would be unable to interpret their tests or do not even know which specialist they should see, directly resulting in delayed CKD diagnosis.

Table 1.

Results for each item pre- and post-intervention for children and family members.

Questions and answers  Children pre  Children post  Family members pre  Family members post 
1. What is a kidney specialist called?
Paediatrician  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Urologist  0% (0)  4.8% (1)  14.3% (3)  4.8% (1) 
Nephrologista  0% (0)  85.7% (18)  76.2% (16)  90.5 (19) 
Kidneyologist  42.9% (9)  4.8% (1)  9.5% (2)  4.8% (1) 
I don't know  52.4% (11)  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
2. Do kidneys hurt?
Yes  38.1% (8)  4.8% (1)  52.4% (11)  23.8% (5) 
Noa  38.1% (8)  95.2% (20)  47.6% (10)  76.2% (16) 
I don't know  23.8% (5)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
3. How many kidneys do we have?
One  23.8% (5)  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Twoa  38.1% (8)  95.2% (20)  100% (21)  100% (21) 
Three  9.5% (2)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Four  19% (4)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
I don't know  9.5% (2)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
4. Kidneys are shaped like…
A lentil  14.3% (3)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
A French beana  9.5% (2)  100% (21)  90.5% (19)  100% (21) 
A tomato  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  9.5% (2)  0% (0) 
A square  19% (4)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
I don't know  52.4% (11)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Head  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
5. The kidneys are located…
Back above your bottoma  23.8% (5)  95.2% (20)  85.7% (18)  95.2% (20) 
Belly  14.3% (3)  0% (0)  4.8% (1)  4.8% (1) 
Chest  28.6% (6)  0% (0)  9.5% (2)  0% (0) 
I don't know  33.3% (7)  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
6. Which organs are responsible for cleaning the blood?
Lungs  9.5% (2)  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  4.8% (1) 
Kidneysa  14.3% (3)  90.5% (19)  81% (17)  90.5% (19) 
Tummy  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Heart  33.3% (7)  0% (0)  19% (4)  4.8% (1) 
I don't know  38.1% (8)  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
7. The waste in the blood is called…
Creatininea  9.5% (2)  90.5% (19)  42.9% (9)  71.4% (15) 
Bilirubin  0% (0)  0% (0)  47.6% (10)  19% (4) 
Glitter  14.3% (3)  0% (0)  4.8% (1)  0% (0) 
Melatonin  28.6% (6)  4.8% (1)  4.8% (1)  9.5% (2) 
I don't know  47.6% (10)  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
8. What can I do to take care of my kidneys?
Not eat sweets /sugar  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Drink water  100% (21)  100% (21)  100% (21)  100% (21) 
Not eat salt  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Do sport  100% (21)  100% (21)  76.2% (16)  100% (21) 
Not eat junk food  100% (21)  100% (21)  71.4% (15)  90.5% (19) 
Not self-medicate  23.8% (5)  4.8% (1)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Not smoke  –  –  61.9% (13)  76.2% (16) 
Not drink alcohol  –  –  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Not take NSAIDs  –  –  0% (0)  0% (0) 
All of the above are correcta  71.4% (15)  95.2% (20)  57.1% (12)  66.6% (14) 
9. Which liquid is most beneficial for the kidneys?
Cola soft drink  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
Orange juice  23.8% (5)  19% (4)  0% (0)  4.8% (1) 
Watera  57.1% (12)  81% (17)  100% (21)  95.2% (20) 
Beer  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
I don't know  19% (4)  0% (0)  0% (0)  0% (0) 
10. HD, PD, Tx are the treatment options
Truea  4.8% (1)  90.5% (19)  HD: 47.6% (10)  HD: 52.4% (11) 
      PD: 52.4% (11)  PD: 52.4% (11) 
      Tx: 38.1% (8)  Tx: 42.9% (9) 
      No tmt: 0% (0)  No tmt: 0% (0) 
False  95.2% (20)  9.5% (2)     
Choose all the correct options  9.5% (2)  14.3% (3)     

McNemar test. p < 0.05; p > 0.05.

HD: haemodialysis; PD: peritoneal dialysis; tmt: treatment; Tx: transplant.

a

Indicates the correct answers in the form.

Compared to other diseases, such as cardiovascular disorders, hypertension, diabetes or cancer, CKD urgently requires more awareness raising and campaigns. Lack of knowledge among the population about CKD and its risk factors favours the development and progression of the disease, is associated with a worse diagnosis and prognosis, and with worse outcomes in renal replacement therapy.10

Ultimately, healthcare professionals are responsible for identifying patients with low health literacy and, in collaboration with teachers, helping to promote the health of the population. New strategic plans that include CKD as a priority disease and that also place children at the centre of their care are urgently needed. The results of this research (to the best of our knowledge, the first to be conducted in Spain on the potential of children as agents of awareness raising and prevention of kidney disease) open up new avenues for nephrology research and initiatives.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the management of the Arco Iris Nursery and Primary School and the teacher of the pupils of the 3rd year of the second cycle, Adriana de la Peña Jiménez-Valladolid, for their faith in the project and their invaluable support. We would also like to thank M. del Mar Ojeda Ramírez, Early Childhood Education teacher and educational psychologist, for her help and advice in adapting the questionnaire to the children's level of knowledge, as well as in the design of teaching resources. Finally, we wish to thank all the pupils and families who participated in the study.

References
[1]
ONT.
CKD: The burden of disease invisible to research funders.
Nefrologia (Engl Ed), 42 (2022), pp. 65-84
[2]
S. Sáenz Martínez, F. Pérez López, C. Martí-García.
Conocimiento sobre la enfermedad renal crónica en la población universitaria de Málaga.
Enferm Nefrol [Internet], 22 (2019), pp. 186-193
[3]
World Health Organization.
Making every school a health-promoting school: global standards and indicators for health-promoting schools and systems, World Health Organization and the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, (2021),
[4]
Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad.
Documento Marco sobre Enfermedad Renal Crónica (ERC) dentro de la Estrategia de Abordaje a la Cronicidad en el SNS [Internet], Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad, (2015),
[5]
M.A. Arenas Jiménez.
Renata, mi nefróloga.
[6]
Fundación Renal Íñigo Álvarez de Toledo.
Tú también nos puedes ayudar a prevenir la enfermedad renal desde la infancia con Renata mi nefróloga, Fundación Renal Íñigo Álvarez de Toledo, (2022),
[7]
M.J. Siebelink, A.A.E. Verhagen, P.F. Roodbol, M.J.I.J. Albers, H.B.M. Van de Wiel.
Education on organ donation and transplantation in primary school; teachers’ support and the first results of a teaching module.
[8]
J.L. Bay, M.H. Vickers, H.A. Mora, D.M. Sloboda, S.M. Morton.
Adolescents as agents of healthful change through scientific literacy development: a school-university partnership program in New Zealand.
Int J STEM Educ, 4 (2017), pp. 15
[9]
J. Pommier, M.R. Guével, D. Jourdan.
A health promotion initiative in French primary schools based on teacher training and support: actionable evidence in context.
Glob Health Promot, 18 (2011), pp. 34-38
[10]
J.A. Green, M.K. Mor, A.M. Shields, M.A. Sevick, R.M. Arnold, P.M. Palevsky, et al.
Associations of health literacy with dialysis adherence and health resource utilization in patients receiving maintenance hemodialysis.
Am J Kidney Dis, 62 (2013), pp. 73-80
Copyright © 2024. Sociedad Española de Nefrología
Download PDF
Idiomas
Nefrología (English Edition)
Article options
Tools
es en

¿Es usted profesional sanitario apto para prescribir o dispensar medicamentos?

Are you a health professional able to prescribe or dispense drugs?